Effect of Mineral, Organic and Bio- Fertilization on Yield and Quality of Parsley (Petroselluinam sativam, L.)

Document Type : Research papers

Authors

1 plant production Dept., Fac. Agric. (Saba Basha) Alexandria University, Egypt

2 Medicinal and Aromatic Res. Dept, A. R. C. Alexandria, Egypt, Div. of Medicinal and Aromatic plants

Abstract

Two field experiments were carried out at the Experimental Farm of the Faculty of Agriculture (Saba Basha), Alexandria University, at Abees region, Alexandria. Egypt during the seasons of 2012/2013 and 2013/2014 to study the effect of NPK fertilizers, organic manure levels and biofertilizers on the growth parameters, chemical composition, and majors compounds of the essential oil of Parsley (Petroselinum sativum, L.). The applied experimental design was randomize complete blocks design with three replicates. The main results could be summarized as follows: (1) The fertilization treatments differently affected the mean values of all studied characters, (2) The application with organic manure (2 ton)/fed + 50% NPK+ Cerealine + phoshorein and organic manure (4 ton)/fed + 50% NPK + Cerealine + phosphorein significantly increased plant height, leaf area index, fresh and dry weight at two cuts as well as chlorophyll a & b, chemical composition (N, P and K%) and Vitamin C content during both seasons. (3) However, the application organic manure 2 ton org/fed + 75% NPK + phosphorein gave the highest of major's compounds (apiol, myristien, B- pinene and B- phellandrene %) during 2012/2013 season. This investigation suggests the need for more studies concerning the effect of NPK fertilizer organic manure and biofertilization on Parsley plant under different environments using different types of soil to reach the optimum combination to achive the best yield.

Keywords

Main Subjects


INTRODUCTION

Petroslinum sativum Mill (parsley) Fam. Apiaceae is a widely cultivated herb used extensively for garnishing and seasoning foods, and for production of an essential oil. Fresh parsley is one of the most popular green herbs. The mature seed is steam distilled to produce parsley seed's, oil and parsley herb oil comes from the plant bearing immature seeds. Parsley herb oil has flavor more like the fresh leaves and is in greater demand than seed oil, which is often distilled from aged seed of low germinability (Simon et al., 1984). The root may, also, be harvested for use as a medicinal herb. Parsley combines well with most foods except sweets. It has a mild taste blends other flavors together, and has a high nutrient's content and used in medicinal, household cosmetic and fragrance (Rashed, 2002).

 

 Fertilization is one of the most important factors limiting the productivity of plants. The intensive use of expensive mineral fertilizers in recent gears results in environmental pollution problems. However, Chemical fertilizers at extremely high rates for along period decreased the potential activity of microflora and the stability of soil organic matter (Hussien, 1995). Additionally, organic manures are in the form of compost, animals manure, farmyard manure (FYM) and green manure organic materials are generally added to soils to improve their physical and chemical properties. They enhance the soil fertility by their composition of macro and microelements, amino acid, organic acids, sugars and organic matter (Abou El- Fadl et al., 1968). Furthermore, biofertilization is an important factor being used to produce products without some mineral fertilizer that cause environmental pollution problems, and high rates of it leads to decrease the potential activity of microflora and the mobility of organic matters. Hence, the attention has been focused on the researches of bio- fertilization to safe alternative to specific chemical fertilizers. Biofertilizers play vital role for increasing the number of microorganisms and accelerate certain microbial process in the rhizosphere of inoculated soil of plants which can change the available forms of some nutrients tobe plants (Kandeel et al., 2001, Rashed, 2002; Mohamed and Abdu, 2004).

 

This research, however, is an attempt to find out the best fertilization  treatments (chemical fertilizer, organic manure and biofertilizer) on the vegetative growth and chemical composition of psarley (Petroselinum sativum, Mill).

 

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two filed experiments were carried out at the Experimental Farm of Faculty of Agric. (Saba Basha) Alexandria University, at Abees region, Alexandria, Egypt, during, the two growing seasons of 2012/2013 and 2013/2014 to study the effect of fertilization treatments (chemical fertilizer, organic manure and bio- fertilization) on growth and chemical composition of parsley( Petroselinum sativum Mill) plants. The experimental design was a complete randomized block design with three replicates.

 

The parsley seeds were sown on November 11th and 14th in the two growing seasons, respectively. The plots area of each was 4 square meters  (2.0m ×2.0m) with 3 rows, the distance between the rows was 50 cm and 10 cm between plants.

 

The chemical fertilizers were applied as ammonium sulphate (20.5%N), calcium superphosphate (15.5% P2O5) and potassium sulphate (48% K2O) at the rates of (100, 100 and 50 kg/fed, respectively) which are the recommended dose.

 

The used biofertilization of bacteria were phosphorein (Bacillusmegatheruim phosphorus dissolving bacteria P.D.B.), cerealine (Azospirillum Lipoferum and Azotobacter chroococcum) which supplied by National Research Center. The inoculation, with phosphorein and cerealine was preformed by coating parsley seed with each product individually using a sticking substance (Arbic gum at 5%) just before sowing.

 

The organic fertilization (Sheap manure) was carried at the rates of 2 and 4 tons/fed, which were applied through the soil preparation before sowing.

 

The recommended dose of NPK was divided in two equal parts, the first one was applied one month after sowing and the second one was applied after the first cut.

 

The tested treatments were conducted as follows:

F1: 100% NPK (control).

F2: 75% NPK + cerealine.

F3: 50% NPK + cerealine + phosphorein.

F4: Organic manure (2 ton/fed) + 75% NPK.

F5: Organic manure (2 ton/fed) + 75% NPK + cerealine.

F6: Organic manure (2 ton/fed) + 75% NPK + phosphorein.

F7: Organic manure (2 ton/fed) + 50% NPK + cerealine+ phosphorein.

F8: Organic manure (4 ton/fed) + 75% NPK.

F9: Organic manure (4 ton/fed) + 75% NPK + cerealine.

F10: Organic manure (4 ton/fed) + 75% NPK + phosphorein.

F11: Organic manure (4 ton/fed) + 50% NPK + cerealine+ phosphorein.

 

The physical and chemical characteristics of the experimental soil and used sheep manure composition are given in Tables (1) and (2). The soil was ananlyzed according to be methods deseribed by Page et al. (1982)

 

Table (1): The physical and chemical properties of the experimental soil in 2012/2013 and 2013/2014 seasons

 

Soil properties

Values

2012/2013

2013/2014

A- Particle size distribution (%)

Sand

Silt

Clay

Soil texture

 

15.00

42.00

43.00

Clay loam

 

14.80

42.20

43.00

Clay loam

B- Chemical properties

pH (1:1)

EC (1:1) dS/m

1- Soluble cations (1:2) (Cmol/kg soil)

K+

Ca++

Mg++

Na++

 

7.90

2.20

 

0.90

4.15

3.10

8.10

 

7.80

2.10

 

0.95

4.20

3.15

8.20

2- Soluble anions (1:2) (Cmol/kg soil)

CO-3+ HCO-3

CL-

SO-4

 

2.70

11.50

0.50

 

2.60

11.70

0.48

Calcium carbonate, %

7.70

7.80

Organic matter, %

1.00

0.90

Total nitrogen, %

0.45

0.47

Avaliable Phosphorus (mg/kg)

3.70

3.80

Avaliable K (mg/kg)

162.3

170.1

 


 

Also, the chemical analysis of the organic manure was carried out according the method of Jackson (1967).

 

Table (2): Analysis of the applied organic manure (sheep manure)

 

pH

7.5

O.M (%)

23.20

O.C (%)

21.00

Total (N%)

2.20

Total (P%)

1.15

Total (K%)

1.45

C/N ratio

11.5:1

 

At harvest dates on January 7th and February 6th in the two season, guarded plants were randomly taken from each plots and the following characteristics  were recorded:

  1. Plant height (cm).
  2. Fresh and dry weights of aerial parts/plant (g).
  3. Leaf area index (cm2).
  4. Chlorophyll (a and b), mg/g fresh weight were determined in fresh leaves samples of the fifth leaf from top at harvest and after 30 days for parsley, using the method by Moran (1982).
  5. The N, P and K contents were determined in the acid digested solution which was prepared according to Hach et al. (1985) using a mixture of hydrogen peroxide and sulfuric acid (4:10).
  • Elements extraction was made on a known weight of the dried samples (0.2 mg).
  • Nitrogen was determined using the microkjeladhl method according to Black (1983).
  • Phosphorus was determined colorimetrically using the method described by Jackson (1967) and Potassium was estimated using flame photometer method according to Richards (1954).
  1. Vitamin (C) content was determined in filtered juice samples and expressed as (mg) ascorbic acid/100 ml fresh juice as described by (A.O.A.C., 1965).
  2. The percentage of major constituents (Apiole, myristiein, ß- pinene, and ß- phellandrene) were estimated by measuring the peak area of the different compounds of the chromatogram according to Heftman (1967) and Gunther and Joseph (1978).        

 

The obtained data were, statistically, analyzed for ANOVA, and L.S.D. values were calculated to test the differences between the studied treatments according to Gomez and Gomez (1984).

 

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

A- Growth parameters and yield:

The obtained results, given in Tables (3 and 4) cleared, that fertilizer treatments exhibited a significant effect on all estimated traits in both seasons. Application of (F6) treatment organic manure (2 ton)/fed + 50% NPK + cerealine + phosphorein and (F11) organic manure (4 ton)/fed + 50% NPK + cerealine + phosphorin significantly, increased plant height, leaf area index, fresh and (g), dry weight (g) at two cuts as well chlorophyll a, b in both seasons. It could be concluded that this positive effect on growth characters and chlorophyll a, b in response to sheep manure levels, may be attributed to increasing maentration in plant tissues (Opera and Asigebu 1996). Also, the phosphate solubilizing bacteria (phasphorein) and nitrogen fixing (cerealine) may increase the synthesis of endogenous phytothormones i.e. IAA, GAs and CKs which play an important role in formation of a big active root system which allow more nutrients, uptake. The previous results agree, more or less, with the findings of Rashed (2002) on parsley, Gad (2001) on Anelthum graveolens; Mohammad et al. (2012) on pimpinella anisum; Abdel- Latif. (2002) on Caruim carvi and Kandeel et al. (2001) and Mohamed and Abdu (2004) on Foeniculum vulgare.   

 

B- Chemical composition and vitamin (C):

The data in Table (4) showed that all treatments of fertilization, affected chemical composition (N, P and K%) and vitamin, (C) content in both seasons. It is clear from data that the highest mean values of chemical composition (N, P and K%) and vitamin (C) content, resulted from the treatments of (F7) 2 ton organic manure/fed + 50% NPK + cerealine + phosphorein and (F11) 4 ton/fed organic manure + 50% NPK + cerealine+ phosphorein in both seasons.

 

The increment of chemical composition (N, P and K%) and vitamin (C) content of plant's leaves using the treatments of organic manure and half dose of NPK and biofertilization; may be attributed to increase in the occupancy root zone of plant as a results of adding fertilization treatments which reflected on nutrients uptake by plants and confirm the previous of vegetative growth. Similar results, more or less were obtained by Kandeel et al. (2001) and Abou El- Maged et al. (2008) on fennel; Rashed (2002) on Petroselinium sativum, Likwise the results showed significant differences for organic manure + biofertilization in the both seasons, which gave the greatest values for all chemical composition.

   

C- Major components percentage of essential oil:

The effect of fertilization treatments on essential oil majors compounds (Apiol, Myristien, ß. Pinene and ß- Phellandrene) percentages are shown in Table (5). The results indicated that using fertilization treatments had significant effect on the studied majors compounds percentage of parsley oil. The application of 2 tons organic manure fed + 75% NPK + phosphorein; gave the highest percentage of majors compounds in 2012/2013 season. Similar results were reported by Darzi et al (2011) on anisum and Ismail et al. (2009) on majoram plant.

 

 

 

 

 

 


Table (3) : Effect of fertilization treatments on vegetative growth at two cut during 2012/2013 and 2013/2014 seasons

Treatments

Plant height (cm)

Leaf area index (cm2)

Fresh weight (g)

2012/2013

2013/2014

2012/2013

2013/2014

2012/2013

2013/2014

1stcut

2ndcut

1stcut

2nd cut

1stcut

2ndcut

1stcut

2nd cut

1stcut

2nd cut

1stcut

2nd cut

F1: NPK (control)

27.23c

27.67d

25.00d

27.23ed

5.20c

3.71c

4.90b

2.98c

138.33i

124.00d

130e

140c

F2: 75% NPK + Cerealine

24.23g

25.17g

24.67d

24.53g

5.40c

3.90b

4.95b

3.38b

163.33e

150.00b

190.5b

150b

F3:50%NPK+Cerealine+ phosphorein.

27.17c

25.17g

24.67d

27.17d

5.81b

4.40b

5.10b

3.50b

198.33d

130.00c

170c

153b

F4: organic manure (2ton/fed) + 75% NPK

27.47b

26.17f

24.33e

27.73c

4.67d

3.10d

4.70c

3.17b

125.00b

110.00e

160cd

146c

F5: organic manure (2ton/fed)+75% NPK+  cerealine

27.64b

28.17c

27.83b

26.77e

4.70d

3.15d

4.55c

3.20b

216.67cb

140.00b

190c

154b

F6: organic anure(2ton/fed)+75%NPK+  phosphorein

26.37d

28.83b

27.33b

27.37cd

5.21b

4.30b

5.15b

3.45b

211.67c

150.00b

180c

144c

F7: organic anure(2ton/fed)+50%NPK+ Cerealine+ phosphorein

28.77a

2967a

29.44a

28.97a

5.20a

5.00a

5.50a

4.10a

231.67a

161.16a

215a

165a

F8: organic manure (4ton/fed)+75%NPK

25.73f

26.33f

25.83c

25.73f

5.75b

4.15b

5.11b

3.36b

156.67g

115.00de

155d

144c

F9:Org.(4ton/fed)+75%NPK+ Cerealine

26.07e

26.83e

25.33c

26.07f

5.80b

4.20b

5.16b

3.26b

185.00d

135.c

195b

155b

F10: organic manur(4ton/fed)+75%NPK+ phosphorein

23.30h

28.83b

24.67d

24.30g

5.90b

4.18b

5.10b

3.30b

195.33d

137.00c

155d

148b

F11: organic manur(4ton/fed)+50%NPK+ Cerealine+phosphorein

28.90a

35.00a

30.00a

29.63a

6.00a

5.01a

5.51a

4.11a

225.33a

156.00a

170c

165a

L.S.D. (0.05)

0.25

0.30

0.40

0.45

0.35

0.40

0.30

0.40

10.30

9.10

9.30

8.90

* Means followed by the same letter (s) in each column are not significantly different at 0.05 level of probability.

 

Table (3) : Cont'd.

Treatments

Dry weight (g)

Chlorophyll (mg/g)

2012/2013

2013/2014

2012/2013

2013/2014

1stcut

2nd cut

1stcut

2nd cut

a

b

a

b

F1: NPK + control

45.77e

38.38g

30.40f

34.70h

1.60d

0.39d

1.58d

0.48b

F2: 75% NPK + Cerealine

46.53d

41.20c

55.60b

44.15b

1.62c

0.31e

1.51f

0.33d

F3:50%NPK+Cerealine+ phosphorein.

42.07g

39.80d

50.70c

35.90g

1.65c

0.39d

1.55e

0.36c

F4: organic manure (2ton/fed) + 75% NPK

55.83b

40.15d

51.8c

52.60c

1.70bc

0.40d

1.60d

0.39c

F5: organic manure (2ton/fed)+75% NPK+ Cerealine

52.80b

41.20c

35.70g

36.70f

1.75bc

0.50b

1.58d

0.48b

F6: organic manure (2ton/fed)+75%NPK+ phosphorein

56.33b

40.60c

40.70e

38.90e

1.74bc

0.52b

1.55e

0.49b

F7: organic manure (2ton/fed)+50%NPK+ Cerealine+  phosphorein

62.80a

53.38a

71.20a

54.41a

2.18a

0.60a

1.90a

0.62a

F8: organic manure (4ton/fed)+75%NPK

42.43g

36.30f

42.60d

40.60d

1.74bc

0.42d

1.66c

0.52b

F9:Org.(4ton/fed)+75%NPK+ Cerealine

56.73b

41.70c

35.40g

36.40f

1.78b

0.46c

1.72b

0.48b

F10: organic manure (4ton/fed)+75%NPK+ phosphorein

49.47c

37.40

34.70g

33.90i

1.72bc

0.40d

1.68c

0.50b

F11: organic manure (4ton/fed)+50%NPK+ cerealine+phosphorein

62.07a

54.20a

71.70a

54.15a

2.20a

0.16a

1.92a

0.63a

L.S.D. (0.05)

1.20

1.00

1.20

1.00

0.10

0.03

0.03

0.03

* Means followed by the same letter (s) in each column are not significantly different at 0.05 level of probability.

 

 

Table (4) : Chemical composition (N, P and K percentages) and vitamin (C) as influenced by fertilization treatments during

                        2013 and 2014 seasons

Treatments

N%

P%

K%

Vitamin (C)

Mg/100ml fresh Juice

2013

2014

2013

2014

2013

2014

2013

2014

F1: NPK ( control )

2.60d

2.75d

0.590.gh

0.602ef

2.37e

2.45e

107.08p

109.30f

F2: 75% NPK + Cerealine

2.75cd

3.10c

0.600eg

0.617d

2.58d

2.50e

109.10eb

110.20ef

F3:50%NPK+Cerealine+ phosphorein.

2.77cd

3.20c

0.595f

0.605e

2.60d

2.65d

109.50e

110.70def

F4: organic manure (2ton/fed) + 75% NPK

2.56e

2.90d

0.585h

0.595f

2.67d

2.70d

110.30de

111.40cde

F5: organic manure (2ton/fed)+75% NPK+ Cerealine

2.80bcd

2.30c

0.610de

0.622d

2.81c

2.85c

111.70de

112.20cde

F6: organic manure (2ton/fed)+75%NPK+ phosphorein

3.10b

3.60b

0.635b

0.650b

2.87bc

2.90c

112.30d

112.80cd

F7: organic manure (2ton/fed)+50%NPK+ Cerealine+  phosphorein

3.50g

4.20a

0.660a

0.670a

3.35a

3.50a

130.40a

135.40a

F8: organic manure (4ton/fed)+75%NPK

2.85bc

3.50b

0.620cd

0.635c

2.67d

2.70d

112.90d

113.40c

F9:Org.(4ton/fed)+75%NPK+ Cerealine

2.90bc

3.50b

0.590gh

0.604ef

2.96b

3.20b

117.90c

120.50b

F10: organic manure (4ton/fed)+75%NPK+  hosphorein

3.00b

3.70b

0.630bc

0.650b

2.97b

3.20b

120.30b

122.40b

F11: organic manure (4ton/fed)+50%NPK+ Cerealine+phosphorein

3.90a

3.30a

0.670a

0.680a

3.40a

3.55a

132.70a

136.30a

L.S.D. (0.05)

0.20

0.25

0.012

0.010

0.015

0.012

2.40

2.30

    * Means followed by the same letter (s) in each column are not significantly different at 0.05 level of probability.

 

Table ( 5): Effect of fertilization treatments on major components (%) in Parsely oil of second season (2013/2014)

Treatments

Apiol

(%)

Myristicin

(%)

B- Pinene

(%)

B- Phellandrene

(%)

F1: NPK + control

17.2e

31.5d

12.5g

5.1cb

F2: 75% NPK + Cerealine

17.5de

32.4c

12.3g

5.3b

F3:50%NPK+Cerealine+ phosphorein.

17.4de

33.2c

14.1c

5.3b

F4: organic manure (2ton/fed) + 75% NPK

17.9c

33.4c

14.2c

5.8e

F5: organic manure (2ton/fed)+75% NPK+ Cerealine

18.3b

34.2b

14.8b

5.9a

F6: organic manure (2ton/fed)+75%NPK+ phosphorein

18.8a

35.3a

15.1a

6.00a

F7: organic manure (2ton/fed)+50%NPK+ Cerealine+ phosphorein

18.4b

35.3a

13.7d

5.9a

F8: organic manure (4ton/fed)+75%NPK

17.9c

34.2b

12.8f

5.2b

F9:Org.(4ton/fed)+75%NPK+ Cerealine

17.2e

34.3b

12.7f

5.4b

F10: organic manure (4ton/fed)+75%NPK+ phosphorein

17.3e

33.5c

12.7f

5.1cb

F11: organic manure (4ton/fed)+50%NPK+ Cerealine+phosphorein

17.3

33.6c

13.2e

5.1cb

L.S.D. (0.05)

0.35

0.42

0.30

0.25

       * Means followed by the same letter (s) in each column are not significantly different at 0.05 level of probability.

Abdel- Latif, T. A. 2002. Effect of organic manure and biofertilizer on caraway plants (Carum carvi, L.) j. Agric. Sci. Mansoura Univ., 27 (5): 3459- 3468.
Abou- El- Fadl, M., S. G. Rizk, A. F. Abdel Ghani, M. K. El- Mofty, M. F. A. Kader S. M. Shehata and F. A. Fdrag. 1968. Utilization of water gycointh as an organic manure with special refute water- bohne helminth. Microbical ARF, 3 (1): 27-34.
Abou- El- Magid, M. M., M. F. Zaki and S. D. Abou- Hussein 2008. Effect of organic manure and different lebels of saline irrigation water on growth, green yield and chemical content of sweet fennel. Aust. J. Basic& Appl. Sci., 2 (1): 90- 98.
A.O. A. C. (Assocition of official Agricultural Chemists). 1965. Official and tentative Methods of analysis 10th ed. 1008P. Washinton D. C.USA.
Black, C. A. 1983. Methods of soil Analysis Part 1and 32. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer Inc. Publ. Madison, Wisconsin, USA.
Darzi, M. T., M. R. Haj Seyed Hadi and F. Rejali 2011. Effect of vermicompost and phosphate bio- fertilizer application on yield and yield components in anise (Pimpinella anisum, L.) Iran. J. Med. Aroma plants, 4(50): 451-465.
Gad, Wessam, M.A.M. 2001. Physiological studies on Foeniculum vulgare, Mill, and Anethum graveolens, L. M. Sc. Thesis, Fac. Agric Kaf- El- Sheikh, Tanta Univ. Egypt.
Gomez, K. A. and A. A. Gomez 1984. Statistical Procedures for Agricultural Research 2nd edition . John Wiley & Sons. Inc., New York.
Gunther, Z. and S. Josaph 1978. Hand Book Series in Chromatography CRC press. Inc.
Hach, C. C., S. V. Brayton and A. B. Kapelove 1985. Powerful kejeldahl nitrogen method using proxy mono sulfuric acid. J. Agric., Food Chem., 33: 1117-1123.
Heftman, E. 1967. Chromatography Reinhold Pub. Crop. New York.
Hussein, M. S. 1995. Response of coriander and dill to different nitrogen sources Egypt. J. Hort., 22 (1):1-10.
Ismail, A. G., E. M. Desouky, Y. Gamal, M. Galal, A. A. Arafa and A. M. Abou Seer 2009. Effect of biofertilizers and organic phosphorus amendment on growth and essential oil of marjoram (Mojorana hortensis, L.) Egypt. Acad, J. Biolog. Sci., 1 (1): 29- 38.
Jackson, M. L. (1967). Soil chemical analysis Prentice Hall of India, Private Limited New Delhi, p:115.
Kandeel, Y.R., Nofal, E.S., Menesi, F.A., Reda, K.A., Taher, M. and Zaki, Z.Y. 2001. Effect of some cultural practices on growth and chemical composition of Foeniculum vulgare, Mill. Proceeding 5th Arabi. Horti. Conf. Ismalia, Egypt, March 24- 28 pp: 61-72.
Mohamed, M.A.H. and M. Abdu. 2004. Growth and oil production of fennel (Foeniculum vulgare Mill.), effect of irrigation and organic fertilization. Bio. Agric. and Hort., 22: 31-39.
Mohammad, T. D., H. S. M. Reza and F. Rejale 2012. Effect of the application of vermicompost and phosphate solubilizing bacterium on the morphological trait and seed yield of anise (Pimpinella anisum, L.) J. Medi. Plant Res., 6 (2): 215- 219.
Moran, R. 1982. Formula determination of chlorophyllous pigment extracted with N, Ndimethyl farmamide, Plant Physicl., 69:1376- 1381.
Opera, C. N. and J. E. Asigbu 1996. Nutrient content of poultry manures and the optimum role for Egyptian fruit yield in a weathered tropical Ultisol Bid., Agric.& Hort., 13: 341- 350.
Rashed, Nahed, M. M. 2002. Effect of fertilization on the growth and storability of some aromatic plants. M. Sc. Thesis, Fac. Agric. Kafer EL-Sheikh, Tanta Univ, Egypt.
Richards, L. A. 1954. Diagnosis and improvement of saline and Alkaline soils. U.S.D.A. Agric. Hand Book No. 60. Gov. Print off.
Simon, J. E., A. F. Chadwick and L. E. Craker 1984. Herbs: An Indexed Bibliography. 1971-1980. The Scientific Literature on Selected Herbs, and Aromatic and Medicinal Plants of the Temperate Zone. Archon Books, 770 pp., Hamden, CT.